In a recent study in Norway, family doctors were trained to ask about drinking only when it connects to the reason a patient came in. A patient with trouble sleeping, high blood pressure, depression, or an irregular heartbeat might get asked about alcohol. The researchers call this pragmatic case finding. It’s meant to close a gap that is very common. A national survey from RTI International found that only 3.5 percent of adults who reported heavy drinking said a provider had advised them to cut back. We actually wrote about that study on this blog.
This applies if you’re looking for alcohol treatment in Panama City, and it applies if you’re just wondering whether to bring up your drinking with your own doctor.
Screening Everyone Is Difficult
The standard approach is to handle every patient basically the same, whether that is handing them a questionnaire, or asking a set of prepared questions. The researchers from the newer study say that takes a lot of time, and may not fit how family doctors see their own jobs.
Bringing Alcohol Up When It Fits
Pragmatic case finding works in the opposite direction from the old methods. Doctors will start with the problems the patient is presenting to them, and see if alcohol could be part of what they are seeing, either as a cause or as something making it worse. The study team built a shortlist of conditions for doing that. A condition made the list if there was good evidence that alcohol affects it, if it’s common in a family doctor’s office, and if cutting back would likely help. Depression, sleep problems, high blood pressure, and atrial fibrillation were on that list of conditions. The doctors in the study kept this list of conditions on a laminated card or sheet in the office.
The Study
The paper was published in the Scandinavian Journal of Primary Health Care. It is good to see that this study is coming out of a general health journal for family doctors, so this issue is being studied outside of the addiction treatment space. Over about six months, the doctors attended four training sessions on pragmatic case finding, on motivational interviewing, and on how alcohol interacts with other addictive drugs. They also learned to use liver blood tests to start conversations with patients.
After that training, the doctors rated their own knowledge, skills, and goals for talking about alcohol. The group of doctors saw improvement in their own abilities to do this. The study authors noted that the differences were statistically significant. They also reported that in their tracked working days, they talked about alcohol with about three patients, up from about two, a pretty big increase. The number of patients who brought up alcohol on their own went from one to nearly two, almost doubling. They saw about the same number of patients per day, around 19 to 20, which is good because the changes did not slow down their ability to serve patients.
The doctors described less stigma around the topic of alcohol and addiction. They talked more about cutting down than about quitting completely, and they described changing a patient’s drinking as a slow process. This is all very valuable information for people like me, those looking at this issue from the perspective of drug and alcohol rehabilitation and treatment.
It’s a Small Study
The study covered only four clinics, and it was not done in the United States. There was no comparison group, and the researchers didn’t track whether anyone drank less or got treatment. Those are weaknesses in the data, so I would like to see this problem get more attention in the United States, and maybe some more studies could happen here.
If Your Doctor Brings It Up
Tell the truth about how much you drink. The doctor is trying to figure out whether alcohol could be contributing to your sleep, your blood pressure, your mood, or your heart rhythm. In the future other conditions could be included. You could ask your own doctor whether a blood test would help, and you could ask what a realistic goal looks like for you and your drinking.
If Your Doctor Doesn’t Ask
Some doctors won’t ask if you don’t bring it up, or they won’t follow up when alcohol is mentioned, which we saw in the study from last month, so you may have to bring your concerns up directly. If you’re seeing someone in Bay County or anywhere in the Florida Panhandle for one of those problems above and you drink regularly, speak up. It’s useful for them to know, and it may change how they treat you.
If you drink heavily every day, talk to a doctor before you stop. Alcohol withdrawal can be dangerous, and a medically supervised detox is a safer way to begin.
If cutting back has been harder than you expected, or you have tried and failed, our residential program for drug and alcohol rehab is in Panama City. Call us today.
By Tim Cannon



